Christmas Eve Cinnamon-Vanilla Custard Pie: 6 Magical Holiday Tips

If there’s one dessert that captures the magic of Christmas Eve in every creamy bite, it’s Christmas Eve Cinnamon-Vanilla Custard Pie. Just saying the name feels like a hug, doesn’t it? Whether you’re juggling last-minute wrapping, entertaining excited kids, or trying to squeeze in a moment of calm before the holiday whirlwind, this pie is your sweet little gift to yourself. It’s simple, soothing, and packed with warm holiday flavor — exactly what a busy woman needs on December 24th.

As someone who spends her days creating chicken recipes (yes, even I take a break from poultry this time of year!), I’m always hunting for desserts that offer comfort without complication. This custard pie checks every box. It’s creamy. It’s gently spiced. It smells like heaven on a snowy evening. And best of all? It’s practically impossible to mess up — a Christmas miracle if there ever was one.

So grab your cinnamon, your coziest sweater, and let’s make the Christmas Eve Cinnamon-Vanilla Custard Pie that your family will beg for every year.

Why You’ll Love This Christmas Eve Cinnamon-Vanilla Custard Pie

There’s something magical about custard pies — they’re nostalgic, comforting, and beautifully simple. But this one? This one brings the classic to a new level with warm cinnamon, rich vanilla, and that silky, dreamlike texture every custard lover craves.

Here’s why this pie will earn a forever spot in your holiday rotation:

• It’s easy. Seriously. If you can whisk, you can make this pie.
• It smells like holiday cheer. Cinnamon + vanilla = instant coziness.
• It’s not overly sweet. Perfect after a big Christmas Eve dinner.
• You can make it ahead. Meaning more time to relax (or chase your kids who are buzzing with Santa excitement).
• It looks impressive. Even though it’s a low-stress recipe, the result looks like something from a bakery window.

Ingredients You’ll Need

(Yes, I’m about to sound like the cooking friend who swears “it’s so easy,” but… it really is.)

• Eggs
  These give the custard its smooth structure — think silky, not stiff. Room-temperature eggs blend more easily and help everything bake evenly.
• Milk & Cream
  The dream team. Cream brings richness, milk lightens it up so it’s never heavy. Whole milk works perfectly if you’re out of cream (it is Christmas Eve, after all — swap guilt-free).
• Sugar
  Just enough to sweeten gently without overpowering the cinnamon-vanilla stars.
• Cinnamon
  The heart of our Christmas Eve flavor. Use ground cinnamon for consistency, but if you want to feel extra fancy, warm the milk with a cinnamon stick for deeper spice.
• Vanilla
  Pure vanilla gives warmth and depth. If you have vanilla bean paste or a scraped vanilla pod, this is their moment to shine.
• Pie Crust
  Homemade butter crust? Amazing.
  High-quality store-bought crust? Also amazing — and saves you precious time.

Blind-baking is the secret to avoiding a soggy bottom (because the only soggy bottoms we accept are in British baking shows, not our own kitchens).

Optional Festive Add-Ins

• A sprinkle of nutmeg for warmth
• A little orange zest for a bright holiday twist

Refer to the recipe card below for precise ingredient measurements and complete nutritional details.

How to Make Christmas Eve Cinnamon-Vanilla Custard Pie

1. Prepare the Crust

Start with your chilled 9-inch pie crust. Gently fit it into your pie dish, line it with parchment, and fill with pie weights (or dried beans — we’ve all been there).

Bake at 375°F (190°C) for 15 minutes.
Remove weights and bake another 5 minutes until lightly golden.

Let it sit while you make the custard.

2. Infuse the Cream

In a saucepan, gently warm:

• Milk
• Cream
• Cinnamon
• Vanilla

Heat on medium until steaming — not boiling. If you’re using a cinnamon stick or vanilla bean, let them steep like a winter tea.

Your kitchen will already start to smell magical at this step.

3. Whisk Eggs & Sugar

In a separate bowl, whisk your eggs and sugar until pale and smooth. This is your custard base.

Slowly (I mean it — slowly!) pour a little warm cream into the egg mixture while whisking. This tempers the eggs so you don’t accidentally scramble them.

Add the rest of the cream mixture in a gentle stream, whisking the whole time.

4. Strain & Fill

For the silkiest custard, pour the mixture through a fine strainer into a clean bowl.

Then pour the custard into your pre-baked crust.

5. Bake With Care

Reduce your oven to 325°F (160°C).

Bake for 35–40 minutes, just until the edges are set but the center has a soft jiggle — think “barely wobbling in the middle.”

6. Cool & Rest

Let the pie cool completely at room temperature, then chill for at least 2 hours. It needs this rest time to fully set and achieve that dreamy texture.

Aneta’s Tip

If you want the smoothest, most luxurious custard, bake the pie in a water bath. Just place the pie dish inside a larger pan, fill with hot water halfway up the sides, and bake. No cracks. Ultra-creamy results.

Tips for the Best Christmas Eve Cinnamon-Vanilla Custard Pie

• Don’t boil the cream. If you see bubbles, turn down the heat.
• Room-temperature eggs are your friend. They blend better and make a smoother custard.
• If the top looks too dark, tent with foil. Cinnamon can brown quickly.
• Give it lots of chill time. Custard needs beauty rest.
• Don’t panic about a tiny jiggle. Jiggle means creamy. No jiggle = overbaked.

And if your custard looks a little lumpy before baking? Don’t stress — that’s why we strain it. Magic, right?

A Little Story From My Kitchen

The first time I made this pie, it wasn’t for a big dinner or a holiday crowd. It was just me, my kids, and a rare quiet moment a couple of nights before Christmas. I had leftover cream in the fridge and a half-used jar of cinnamon sitting on the counter (because which mom isn’t fighting spice cabinet chaos in December?).

I threw together a simple custard pie, and my kids ended up loving it so much that they asked for “the Christmas Eve pie” again the next night. And the next. Since then, it’s become a sweet little tradition — the one dessert we all look forward to as our way of kicking off Christmas.

I hope it becomes something special in your home, too.

FAQs About Christmas Eve Cinnamon-Vanilla Custard Pie

Bring the Magic Home This Holiday

As you fasten the last bows, light your candles, or settle in with your family, this Christmas Eve Cinnamon-Vanilla Custard Pie is the perfect sweet companion. It’s comforting, it’s festive, and it brings a sense of calm and warmth right when you need it most.

If you’re looking for a dessert that brings joy without stress, this is your moment. Go ahead — make the pie, pour a warm drink, and let the holiday magic fill your kitchen.

Happy Christmas Eve, friends — and happy cooking!

More Holiday Recipes You’ll Love

If this Christmas Eve Cinnamon-Vanilla Custard Pie has you in a cozy, festive mood, here are a few more delicious recipes your family will adore. Each one adds its own holiday magic — perfect for planning your Christmas menu or simply treating yourself to something wonderful.

• Start your meal with a bright and refreshing festive side like the Christmas Salad — it’s crunchy, colorful, and pairs beautifully with any holiday spread.
• If you’re craving another sweet treat, the Gingerbread Cheesecake Cookies are soft, spiced, and absolutely irresistible (prepare for them to disappear fast).
• For a show-stopping main course, the Christmas Stuffed Beef Tenderloin delivers big holiday flavor and major “wow” factor at the table.
• And if you want something warm and comforting for those chilly December evenings, you’ll fall in love with the Creamy Mushroom Chicken and Wild Rice Soup — it’s soothing, hearty, and perfect for winter nights.

Print